Galton's problem

The Galton problem is named after Francis Galton, the nineteenth-century British polymath, who became embroiled in a celebrated exchange about the logic of comparative analysis with the anthropologist Edward Tylor . In 1889, Tylor published an article which purported to show clear correlations between the economic and familial institutions of a wide range of past and present societies, and attempted to explain these in functionalist terms. Galton's rejoinder argued that correlations between social institutions might not only arise under pressure of functional exigencies (that is, through processes operating within societies), but also as an effect of cultural diffusion between societies. In this way he questioned Tylor's assumption that each of his national cases represented an independent observation (see the debate in the Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 1889).
This problem of distinguishing between autonomous institutional development on the one hand, and institutional development influenced by cultural diffusion on the other, remains a central issue in comparative macrosociology. For example, it is plausible to argue that the national institutions associated with the emergence of modern welfare states have in different ways been influenced by the examples of the Beveridge Plan for post-1945 Britain, nineteenth-century Bismarckian social policy in Germany, or the contemporary so-called Scandinavian model. Indeed, some observers argue that the process of globalization , the emergence of the world-system , and policies of certain multinational corporations and political organizations are accelerating and intensifying the effects of cultural diffusion, to the point at which these undermine the very possibility of a comparative macrosociology based on ‘independent’ national observations: we may be moving towards a world in which N = 1.
Empirically, the problems posed for cross-national comparative analysis by processes of cultural diffusion seem to vary across different spheres of social life, being particularly pronounced in the study of economic and social policy (where governments purposively do often emulate each other). Similarly, it is clear that theorists wishing to develop general accounts of rebellion that emphasize indigenous causes must recognize that revolutionaries have everywhere learned from each other, so that (for example) the course of the Chinese revolution was in part shaped by the earlier Russian experience. Elsewhere, however, such as in the study of class differentials in educational attainment, there is evidence to suggest that national variations are in fact largely attributable to processes of social selection which are distinctive to indigenous institutions-despite the apparent cross-national similarities in programmes of educational expansion and reform. It is also possible to model cross-national interdependence into comparative macrosociology, for example by using event-history analysis to study how institutional and policy development is affected both by domestic factors, and by the timing of cross-national influences of particular kinds.
For an excellent discussion of the implications of Galton's problem for the methodology of comparative macrosociology, of both a case-oriented (qualitative) and variable-oriented (quantitative) kind, and of wider problems of theory development and testing in this field, see the symposium in volume 16 of the journal Comparative Social Research (1997). See also comparative sociology ; function.

Dictionary of sociology. 2013.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Galton's problem — Galton’s problem, named after Sir Francis Galton, is the problem of drawing inferences from cross cultural data, due to the statistical phenomenon now called autocorrelation. The problem is now recognized as a general one that applies to all… …   Wikipedia

  • Galton-Watson-Prozess — Der Galton Watson Prozess, benannt nach dem britischen Naturforscher Francis Galton (1822–1911) und seinem Landsmann, dem Mathematiker Henry William Watson (1827–1903), ist ein spezieller stochastischer Prozess, der benutzt wird, um die… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Bienaymé-Galton-Watson-Prozess — Der Galton Watson Prozess, benannt nach dem britischen Naturforscher Francis Galton (1822 1911) und seinem Landsmann, dem Mathematiker Henry William Watson (1827 1903), ist ein spezieller stochastischer Prozess, der benutzt wird, um die… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Standard cross-cultural sample — The standard cross cultural sample is a sample of 186 cultures, used by scholars engaged in cross cultural studies.OriginCross cultural research entails a particular statistical problem, known as Galton s problem: tests of functional… …   Wikipedia

  • List of statistics topics — Please add any Wikipedia articles related to statistics that are not already on this list.The Related changes link in the margin of this page (below search) leads to a list of the most recent changes to the articles listed below. To see the most… …   Wikipedia

  • List of mathematics articles (G) — NOTOC G G₂ G delta space G networks Gδ set G structure G test G127 G2 manifold G2 structure Gabor atom Gabor filter Gabor transform Gabor Wigner transform Gabow s algorithm Gabriel graph Gabriel s Horn Gain graph Gain group Galerkin method… …   Wikipedia

  • Cross-cultural studies — Cross cultural studies, sometimes called Holocultural Studies, is a specialization in anthropology and sister sciences (sociology, psychology, economics, political science) that uses field data from many societies to examine the scope of human… …   Wikipedia

  • Douglas R. White — Occupation Anthropologist Known for Network Analysis and Ethnographic Problems, Complexity research, Standard cross cultural sample Douglas R. White (born …   Wikipedia

  • Detlef Jahn — Detlef Günter Jahn (* 5. April 1956 in Duisburg) ist ein deutscher Politikwissenschaftler und seit 1999 Inhaber des Lehrstuhls für Vergleichende Regierungslehre an der Ernst Moritz Arndt Universität Greifswald. Leben Nach einem Studium der… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • diffusion — diffusion, diffusionism Diffusion refers to the spread of cultural attributes from one culture to another through contact between different cultural groups. Diffusion theory developed in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, in opposition to… …   Dictionary of sociology

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.